Baking DIY Homesteading Recipes

Sourdough Starter ~ Failure to Success

 How I Finally Figured Out My Sourdough Starter

This page contains affiliate links. Purchasing from these helps to support our site, giving us a small commission without increasing the rate you pay. Thank you for your support of A Chick And Her Garden.

I love bread. It’s a fault of mine.

I watch people order burgers with no bun and make pizzas with cauliflower. Even though I realize that this is for health reasons, bread is just not something that I am willing to give up. Especially sourdough bread!

Sourdough Bread has to be my favorite! So recently I started looking up how to make my own starter. I read a few posts about it and thought it seemed fairly simple, so I gave it a shot.

People tell me that I have a lot of patience because I work with young children. Well, I guess I use it all up on them, Nick, and my dogs because I did not have it when it came to waiting on my starter!

One of the recipes that I read stated that it would be ready in four to five days. OK, I can handle that. So at day four I tested it. The starter was not ready.

Fine, day five, not ready and looked worse than day four! I was ready to chuck it but decided to fiddle with it and gave it one more day. Success! It was frothy and had the perfect sweet/sour smell.

Time to make bread right? That’s what they said. “Now try our recipe for sourdough bread!” I tried, it failed. Found another recipe. It failed.

So I searched around and found in the comments of one of the recipes that sourdough starter is not ready for bread making for at least a month! The yeast is not strong enough at this point to raise bread, but it is ready for things like pretzels and english muffins.

How To Get Your Starter Started

After playing around a bit, I finally figured it out. It’s a fairly simple process, you just need what I had been lacking. Patience, along with equal parts flour and water and a glass or plastic container.

For mine I used a one quart mason jar, and plan to upgrade the next time I get to the store. Start with 1/4 cup flour (I used all-purpose, unbleached) and 1/4 cup of water.

Pin Me For Later!!Sourdough Starter

On Day 1…

Add these to your mason jar and you are supposed to stir it. I was making a mess because it just kept sticking to my spoon so I’ve had more luck just adding the lid tightly and giving it a good shake! After this I give it a shake every so often throughout the day.

Day 2…

Your little yeast buddies need fed! You should see some bubbles on the top from the natural yeast. Again add equal parts flour and water and give it a shake. Shake it a again a few more times again during the day.



Day 3, 4, 5… Until Ready

Repeat the same process. If you start to run out of room just dump some off, it will continue to grow.

To find out if your starter is all set, drop a spoonful into lukewarm water. If it sinks, you are going to have to keep waiting. If it floats, you’re all set for pretzels and english muffins!

It should look like this when it’s ready…



To Care For Your Starter After This…

You have two options. Store it at room temperature and feed it daily (sometimes twice if the weather is warm. Or you can store it in the refrigerator and feed it once a week.

My starter is past the initial part so tomorrow I’ll be making english muffins. Hopefully this will hold me off for the next month waiting to make my bread!


What are some baking skills that you have had to try and try to get just right? Share in the comments!

Shared on:
Our Simple Homestead Hop

Homestead Blog Hop

Check out a few of my sourdough recipes! Dangerously Addicting Sourdough Cinnamon Rolls, Sinful Sourdough Pretzels, and Sourdough English Muffins.

  • Pingback: Must Haves For The Homestead Kitchen -()

  • Pingback: Sourdough English Muffins -()

  • Pingback: The Homesteader Hop #29 - A Chick And Her Garden()

  • Thanks for this! I have had bad luck with making sourdough starters. Looks like I’ll have to try again, now! I’ll let you know how it turns out!


      Thanks so much Travis! I look forward to hearing how it works out!


    Your starter looks a lot lighter than mine! What kind of flour did you use? I used Rye for my last bunch, and it was definitely darker, and the bubbles were lots bigger. The bread was quite dense, too, so I’m not sure if that’s because of the starter or the recipe? It’s all a big experiment, right?


    It always amazed me that yummy sour dough is just water and flour! Yum!

  • Pingback: Homesteader Blog Hop #29 - Back 2 Simple Life()

%d bloggers like this: